Top 5 Softest Mattresses you Can Buy Online

Nest Plush Bed

Online mattress brands try to appeal to the average sleeper but that often leaves out those who want a soft or firm bed. They’re trying to streamline choices to keep prices down but you’ll find most are at about a 6/10 on the firmness scale.

1. Amerisleep AS5

Softness rating 3/10
Depth: 14″
Consumer Reports rating: 65/100
Material: All foam or hybrid available
Price for a queen: $1899

Customer Review:
I love my Amerisleep mattresses and wouldn’t buy anything else after having these. They are soft yet firm and don’t wear even after years, and sometimes I am in the bed for days or weeks at a time due to illness. Never made an impression on the bed from sitting in it for years, amazing. If you have trouble sleeping because of Fibromyalgia this is the bed for you! The AS3 is a little softer and works better for me.

I Want One

2. Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Hybrid, Plush

Softness rating 3/10
Depth: 13.5″ deep
Consumer Reports rating: 74/100
Material: Hybrid
Price for a queen: $1499

Customer Review:
The mattress fabric itself is not like any other mattress fabric I’m aware of. I can’t even explain the softness. But it’s a thick, cooling, luxurious serious quality cozy comfort kind of softness. I went all over town looking at $$$$$ mattresses but still found nothing even close to this. Additionally, I sleep hot. I mean feel like I’m wrapped in plastic and stuffed in an oven with the broiler on high kind of hot. Suffocating hot. And would always wake up with sore hips, shoulders and back. I just thought it was my lot in life. I’m willing to spend decent coin on good mattresses—within reason, but always ended up with long dreadful nights. I actually dreaded going to bed because nights were so bad. This mattress was the game-changer. 

Nest Plush Bed I Want One

3. Saatva Plush Soft

Softness rating 3/10
Depth: Choose from 11.5″ or 14.5″ deep
Consumer Reports rating: N/A
Material: Hybrid (foam and coils)
Price for a queen: $1199 (11.5″)

READ  Our Top Picks: Heavy Duty Mattress Bag for Moving

Customer Review:
We are very glad we picked the plush soft mattress over the luxury firm. I have joint pain and often have tense muscles and hard mattresses can be tough to get comfortable on. The plush soft is dense and supportive, the edge support really is there! We have had “euro too/soft” mattresses in the past but after trying Saatva, those old mattresses really were just stuffed on top. The mattress didn’t seem as soft as we thought we needed at first but after a few nights, it’s very relaxing to sleep on. Plenty of support while not pushing on tender joints as a side sleeper…we are very glad we bought the plush.

Saavta plush mattress I Want One

4. Puffy Lux Mattress

Softness rating 4/10
Depth: 12″ deep
Consumer Reports rating: N/A
Material: All foam
Price for a queen: $1495

Customer Review:
We received our Puffy over a week ago. I have to say That it’s the most comfortable mattress that I ever slept on! My husband and I have been married for over 5 years , and we have already been through 2 mattresses. The one was the I Comfort that we paid $3400 for. That mattress felt awesome at first, then in two months it started getting dips in it from our bodies. That made our backs hurt. We gave it away. Then we decided to go with a firm Beauty Rest, It felt okay, but 3 years later our backs were aching every morning! I searched for the the top 10 mattresses of 2020 and Puffy was the number one. I told my husband about it and he was very skeptical about ordering a mattress over the internet. I told him about the 101 day trial period, so he agreed to it. I have to say that we absolutely love our Puffy and and the king size pillow that came with it. We both wake up feeling so refreshed! Thank you Puffy for giving us the best night’s sleep ever!

Puffy Lux soft mattress I Want One

Also check out our popular list of mattresses with free sleep trials

READ  5 Little Monkeys Mattress Adds New Queen Size Beds

5. Brooklyn Bedding Brooklyn Signature Hybrid – Plush

Softness rating 4/10
Depth: 11.5″
Consumer Reports rating: N/A for soft/plush
Material: Hybrid
Price for a queen: $949

Customer Review:
I have had this mattress for approximately two months and I absolutely love it. Honestly it didn’t even feel like I had to break it in. I have had a chronic back pain for 4 years now and this bed makes my back feel better and I feel like my pain might go away soon because of the bed. Perfect combo of (support – intersprings and comfort – memory foam). My brother has an expensive interspring mattress and was blown away about how comfy this bed is. The price is great and it is made in the US. Thank you Brooklyn Bedding for making an awesome bed that has helped me improve my health.

The soft model is very, very soft and plush, and perfect for strict side sleepers. It supported my back very well and provided pressure relief for my hips and shoulders. The soft model is dollar-for-dollar, I think, one of the best mattresses you can buy.”

I Want One

Leave a Reply